Search This Blog

Showing posts with label governance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label governance. Show all posts

Friday, 8 November 2024

Swaziland Newsletter No. 852 – 8 November 2024

 

Swaziland Newsletter No. 852 – 8 November 2024

News from and about Swaziland, compiled by Global Aktion, Denmark (www.globalaktion.dk) in collaboration with Swazi Media Commentary (www.swazimedia.blogspot.com), and sent to all with an interest in Swaziland - free of charge.

 

eSwatini ranking in Mo Ibrahim governance report worsening

Emmanuel Ndlangamandla, Times of eSwatini, 4 November 2024

SOURCE 

The Mo Ibrahim Foundation released the 2024 Ibrahim Index of African Governance (IIAG), the latest iteration of the biennial dataset assessing governance performance and trends in the 54 African countries over the decade 2014-2023.

…. Eswatini governance, unfortunately, is among the deteriorating countries.  To this end, Eswatini’s overall Governance score has deteriorated over the last decade (2014-2023) and has done so at an accelerated pace over the most recent five years (2019-2023). With a score of 44.5 (out of 100.0), Eswatini ranks 35th (out of 54) in overall Governance in 2023. It is critical that the current Administration led by His Excellency Russell Dlamini and Parliament should analyse this report and take measures to improve the worse performing areas.  Without good governance, emaSwati will continue to suffer!

To read the full report, click here

http://www.times.co.sz/thinking-aloud/147877-eswatini-ranking-in-mo-ibrahim-governance-report-worsening.html

 

eSwatini health campaign bundles HPV vaccination with other critical interventions in schools

By Nonduduzo Kunene, VaccinesWork, 31 October 2024

SOURCE 

Eswatini's EPI chief Xolisiwe Dlamini tells VaccinesWork that the first-of-its kind initiative is all about making the most of the resources at the small country’s disposal.

In the chilly middle months of this year, the largest vaccination initiative Eswatini has seen in three years brought both human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccines and COVID-19 jabs onto 900 school campuses, with mobile health teams also folding in a deworming blitz and nutrition survey.

Expanded Programme on Immunization (EPI) director Xolisiwe Dlamini told VaccinesWork that the campaign’s patchwork structure reflected the tiny southern African country’s determination to do “the most” with the resources at their disposal.

At the height of the effort, said Dlamini, 300 health workers, split into 65 volunteer-supported teams, were out vaccinating thousands of girls against HPV, the cause of the vast majority of cases of cervical cancer worldwide, and kids of both sexes against COVID-19. Between vaccines, dewormers and nutritional supplements, the aim was to reach a total of 300,000 students. Final numbers are still being collated following the campaign’s close in mid-October, but Dlamini indicates that early analysis suggest more than 70% of the target was achieved.

Launched in June by Minister of Health Mduduzi Matsebula, it is a collaboration between the Ministries of Health and Education. 

The campaign brought critical health care interventions to the learners at both primary and high school levels. Girls aged 9–14 years are the target group for HPV vaccination, while children 12 years and older were eligible for COVID-19 vaccination. All pupils were offered deworming. Kids aged 6–19 years were given nutritional supplements “as per need”, Dlamini explained.

The integrated campaign is of a second act. In 2023, Eswatini launched the HPV Vaccine in Schools campaign, designed to reach 30,000 girls between 9 and 14 years old with the cancer-blocking shot. That experience appears to have taught agenda-setters that sending health teams onto school grounds is an opportunity not to be squandered.

“The deworming service aims to address bilharzia and soil-transmitted parasitic intestinal worms that cause various diseases. These parasitic diseases cause significant deaths worldwide, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa. In a previous mapping exercise, it was revealed that 15% of school-going children were infected with bilharzia disease and 5.6% of school-going children were infected with soil-transmitted diseases,” said Dlamini.

“The services are free, and they are an effort by the government to ensure that Eswatini’s future is filled with emaSwati who are healthy, educated and productive.”

To read more of this report, click here

https://www.gavi.org/vaccineswork/eswatini-health-campaign-bundles-hpv-vaccination-with-critical-interventions-schools

 

Over 2 000 children surviving on one meal a day

By Sabelo Gwebu, eSwatini News, 2 November 2024

SOURCE 

MALKERNS: A community tells a different story in the fast-improving town of Malkerns.

The Mangozeni Township, nestled in this small town known for its vibrant pineapple farms and scenic landscapes, shows a picture of hardship, neglect and the daily struggle for survival. The township is home to over 2 000 children under nine and is facing a crisis that demands urgent attention from both local authorities and non-governmental organisations (NGOs).

As local Social Motivator Dumile Maphalala recorded, over 2 000 children depend on a soup kitchen meal for survival. Mangozeni is less than 600 square metres in size, but because of the situation, two soup kitchens, Great Commission and Malkerns Soup Kitchen, have set up base. The biggest struggle now is what to feed the hungry mouths.

“The biggest challenge of Mangozeni is the frequent pregnancies. Most of these children stay with either one of their parents, and most are unemployed. “The only job for the residents is seasonal, which is working at Swazi Can during the citrus season,” Maphalala said. Mangozeni is characterised by its poor living conditions, where families grapple with extreme poverty and limited access to essential resources like electricity and water.

Water is available at E1 Lilangeni per 20 litres, but some households cannot afford that. For many residents, a daily meal is a luxury, while a mere E20 for bread is as scarce as water in the Kalahari Desert. The community’s reliance on these soup kitchens highlights the urgent need for food security and, most importantly, social support. Maphalala, a dedicated social motivator in the township, is vocal about the alarming issues facing the township. She points out that Mangozeni is grappling with a high rate of teenage pregnancies and a growing population.

The lack of employment opportunities in the area has created a desperate situation, leading many mothers to allegedly turn to sex work as a means of survival. With most jobs in the town tied to the seasonal demands of the pineapple farms, work is often irregular and insufficient to meet the needs of families. “This precarious economic situation leaves little room for parental engagement, further exacerbating the challenges faced by the children.

“The impact of poverty on child development is profound, and the children of Mangozeni are no exception,” Maphalala lamented. She continued that without proper care and supervision, these young lives are at risk of falling into cycles of neglect and deprivation. She added that as social workers, they are deeply concerned about the long-term implications of such neglect, which can hinder children’s physical, emotional and cognitive development. “One of the pressing issues facing Mangozeni is the lack of birth certificates for many children.

“The parents, mostly teenagers, do not understand that registration is a critical step in ensuring that children have access to essential services, such as education and healthcare,” she added. Visibly, the situation in Mangozeni is a small-scale, broader societal issue faced by many communities in the country. While the government has made strides in addressing poverty and improving social welfare, the challenges faced by the township residents highlight the need for more targeted interventions.

To read more of this report, click here

http://www.times.co.sz/news/147856-over-2-000-children-surviving-on-one-meal-a-day.html

 

More emaSwati dying of snake bites amid shortage of drugs in public hospitals

By Musa Mdluli, Swaziland News, 1 November, 2024

SOURCE 

MBABANE: More emaSwati are reportedly dying of snake bites amid shortage of drugs in public hospitals and, with the antivenom medication being found only at the Luke Commission.

This means any citizen who might be attacked by snakes in areas far away from the Luke Commission, might die along the way while being transported to the health facility, a person bitten by a Black Mamba normally collapse within a few minutes.

A questionnaire was sent to Health Minister Mduduzi Matsebula, however, he had not responded at the time of compiling this report.

Reached for comments on Friday afternoon, Mayibongwe Masangwane, the Secretary General(SG) of the Swaziland Democratic Nurses Union(SWADNU) confirmed that, the whole country is facing shortage of antivenom, a medication for snake bites.

“It’s true, the whole country is facing shortage of antivenom”, he said.

It has been disclosed that, a relative of a prominent public figure “is among those who recently died” of snakes bite amid shortage of the antivenom.

Eswatini is facing a worsening health crisis triggered by royal extravagant spending and corruption in the public administration, dozens have died since the crisis erupted.

 

HIV prevalence high among disabled in eSwatini - FODSWA

By Musa Simelane, eSwatini Observer, 3 November 2024

SOURCE 



Persons with disabilities face a heightened risk of HIV infections in the country as they are vulnerable to sexual violation and are largely excluded from HIV/AIDS educational outreach programmes.

This highlight was made by Bongani Makama, President of the Federation of Organisations of Disabled Persons in Swaziland (FODSWA) at the World AIDS Day 2024 commemoration launch at St Joseph’s Primary School (Mzimpofu).

This year’s global theme is ‘Take the Rights Path’, which has been localised to: Nkwe! Eswatini Take the Rights Path to End AIDS.

He said females, especially those with cerebral palsy, have a high HIV prevalence since they are taken advantage of by shady elements in the communities, who capitalise on the fact that they cannot talk and have physical and cognitive challenges.

This leads to cases of sexual assault and, ultimately, increased rates of HIV transmission. Some even end up pregnant unknowingly, and cannot communicate effectively or identify the culprits.

“Persons with disabilities are also more vulnerable to HIV and AIDS due to a range of factors, including limited access to education and healthcare, heightened discrimination, and, often, a lack of tailored outreach and support. This is particularly concerning, as persons with disabilities represent a population that, historically, has been under served in health programmes,” explained Makama.

To read more of this report, click here

http://new.observer.org.sz/details.php?id=22924

 

SWAZI MEDIA COMMENTARY

Find us:

Blog: https://swazimedia.blogspot.com/

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/142383985790674

X (formerly Twitter): https://twitter.com  @Swazimedia

 

Friday, 10 May 2024

Swaziland Newsletter No. 826 – 10 May 2024

 

Swaziland Newsletter No. 826 – 10 May 2024

News from and about Swaziland, compiled by Global Aktion, Denmark (www.globalaktion.dk) in collaboration with Swazi Media Commentary (www.swazimedia.blogspot.com), and sent to all with an interest in Swaziland - free of charge.

 

eSwatini among Africa’s worst governed nations

by Sibusiso Dlamini, eSwatini Observer, 6 May 2024

SOURCE 

Eswatini is among the top 10 worst-governed nations in Africa, according to World Economics, a respected UK-based research organisation.

The United Nations defines good governance as the process where public institutions conduct public affairs and manage public resources in a manner that promotes the rule of law and the realisation of human rights (civil, political, economic, social and cultural).

The good governance ranking, according to the organisation, is assessed through four main indexes; corruption perception, rule of law, press freedom, and political rights, with each of them given equal weight.

The comprehensive assessment of the governance dynamics expose glaring deficiencies across these benchmarks and systemic issues hindering progress and development in the country, from rampant corruption and political instability to a disregard for the rule of law.

….

Public Sector Associations who represent civil servants in various sectors said the index’s findings were believable to them as its findings was a lived experience for them, emphasising that a majority of their issues stem from bad governance.

“There are no lies to that at all because working with government exposes poor governance on a daily and it is incredibly frustrating,” said Swaziland National Association of Government Accounting Personnel (SNAGAP) Secretary, Phumzile Masilela, reacting to the Index.

“There's no transparency, no respect for workers' rights, and even the law is disregarded,” she added, emphasising the frustrations encountered within government's operations.
She complained of corruption within government and said it had planted an attitude and spirit of incompetency.

“There are people who do as they please because they are connected, and once you try to be vocal about it, you are ostracised and victimised, which is bad governance of the highest order,” she stated. Masilela also accused government of bad communication, and shone light on the fact that the country could not chart a path towards inclusive growth and development without concerted efforts towards comprehensive governance reform.

“Until we commit to that, the new era of prosperity and stability will remain nothing but a pipe dream,” she said, further speaking against the introduction of the Performance Management System (PMS) without provision of working tools.

Similarly, President of the Swaziland National Association of Teachers (SNAT), Mbongwa Dlamini, said the Index was a true reflection of the country, calling to attention the pervasive corruption in the nation and its impact on the education sector. “Nothing is transparent, from the hiring of teachers to promotions, so imagine what that does to the spirit of the professionals in the profession, let alone the learning process when educators have to teach while dispirited,” he quipped.

Dlamini warned that it is high time the government realises that bad governance has far-reaching consequences, in particular on critical sectors such as education.

To read this full report, click here

http://new.observer.org.sz/details.php?id=22423

 

Prime Minister urges workers to build own clinics, private schools and make money amid collapsed health, education system

By Bongiwe Dlamini, Swaziland News, 6 May, 2024

SOURCE 

MBABANE: Prime Minister (PM) Russell Mmiso Dlamini who attended the Workers Day Celebration at the Prince of Wales Sports Group on Wednesday [1 May 2024], did not come with a solution on how his administration will create jobs for workers but instead, he urged nurses and teachers to build their own clinics and private schools in order to make money.

This is contained in a written statement that was supposed to be delivered by the PM on Wednesday, the Prime Minister (PM)had to flee for safety after being stopped by angry workers from addressing the May Workers Day Celebration.

“On this May Day, I would like to make propositions that will transform our lives as workers. Primarily, I would like to motivate that we can be better than where we are today and our future can be brighter if we maintain the right mindset. Workers, for instance, can build their own banks that will enable us to access finance at low rates. Through these banks, we can lend even to our employers and charge them reasonable interest rates. Teachers can build private schools and make a decent living from that, just as we have other international schools in the country. Nurses can build private clinics and hospitals and make a decent living from that as well”, said the Prime Minister (PM).

The sentiments of the PM comes amid a collapsed health and education system in the midst of corruption in the public administration and royal extravagant spending.

Reached for comments by this Swaziland News on Monday afternoon Wander Mkhonza, the Secretary General of the Amalgamated Trade Union of Swaziland (ATUSWA) criticized the statement of the Prime Minister, saying privatization of basic services like health and education will not improve the wellbeing of the people.

“While we agree that workers must everyday work on improving their financial independence, we as workers do not agree with the views of Prime Minister on workers building private clinics and private schools precisely because we don't believe that privatisation basic necessities like health and education improves the general wellbeing of our people. Private institutions do not work on a mandate to improve lives but work to make profits and the detrimental of those that do not have the means. It is therefore wrong for government to suggest that workers must build businesses that would somehow replace the social responsibility of government”, said the well-known unionist.

 

Warning on syndicate harvesting body parts

By Sithembile Hlatshwayo, Times of eSwatini, 7 May 2024

SOURCE 

MBABANE: The Office of the Prevention of People Trafficking and People Smuggling has warned members of the public to be on the lookout for a syndicate harvesting human body parts and trafficking of same.

This warning follows revelations by some victims who said they survived the trap by a certain woman who had lured them after running an advert in this publication, purporting to be looking for a helper. A post was also run on the social media pages attracting attention from desperate job seekers.

Head of Secretariat- Prevention of People Trafficking and People Smuggling at the Prime Minister’s Office Nompumelelo Lukhele, urged the nation to carefully study details on adverts and social media posts regarding job opportunities. Lukhele said the location was important to get an idea of who the people offering the jobs were and where they came from. In the process, Lukhele said the job seekers should get clear particulars of the advertisers.

According to Lukhele, it was difficult for the job seekers to know who the people were, hence it was safer to avoid going to the location sent by those offering the jobs alone. She said the companion should wait until the interview was over in either the office or home, where it was taking place, in the case where helpers were being sought. The head of secretariat added that in the event the job seeker had suspicions about the offer not being authentic, they should go with their instinct and not show up.

To read more of this report, click here

http://www.times.co.sz/news/144981-warning-on-syndicate-harvesting-body-parts.html

 

‘You are loved’: A clinic for at-risk people in eSwatini

Doctors Without Borders, 2 May 2024

SOURCE 

The small but bustling town of Matsapha in Eswatini is known for its industrial businesses and textile firms. Women from across the country come here seeking employment opportunities, often in factories offering minimal pay. 

Known as a town “where the buyer meets the seller,” Matsapha is also a hub for sex work. This year, Doctors Without Borders/MĂ©decins Sans Frontières (MSF), in collaboration with stakeholders from Eswatini's Health Ministry and community leaders, officially opened a clinic, which the local community has named “Sitsandziwe,” translating to “you are loved.”

The clinic’s scope of health coverage was informed by a 2022 MSF study on sexually transmitted infections (STIs), which identified a significant prevalence of STIs, particularly impacting people between the ages of 18 to 29.

Matsapha is also a welcoming place for the LGBTQI+ community, and has hosted events to encourage marginalized groups to seek health care.

In response to the need for an inclusive and comprehensive sexual health clinic, Sitsandziwe aims to offer effective and convenient sexual health services. The team provides all services free of charge, while ensuring a safe and private environment.

Addressing the STI burden is a long-term endeavor that involves not just medical solutions but also tackling social challenges.

“The ultimate goal of the clinic's activities is to gather data, identify challenges, and uncover opportunities for the national program, leading to policy changes. These could include the introduction of lab-based STI diagnosis and treatment, as well as hepatitis services at primary health clinics,” said Dr. Hayk Karakozian, MSF medical coordinator in the clinic.

To read more of this report, click here

https://www.doctorswithoutborders.org/latest/you-are-loved-clinic-risk-people-eswatini

 

Good Shepherd’s life-changing surgery on kids with disabilities

By Wonderboy Dlamini, eSwatini Observer, 8 May 2024

SOURCE 



Good Shepherd Catholic Hospital has recorded in its history books the first ever procedure known as gastrocnemius recession and other procedures on four children with disabilities.

The four children who were initially diagnosed with cerebral palsy and clubfoot had severe joint contractures and deformities.

The operations to lengthen and straightening the hands and feet were performed last week at the hospital's theatre by a team of doctors from the United Kingdom (UK).

The team was invited to the country by one of the hospital's volunteer surgeons, Dr Joseph Northway. 

Explaining about the procedure, Dr Alex Aarvold, a visiting surgeon, said it was all about helping children with disabilities.

“The surgeries were to help these children stand and perform tasks independently. We screened nine children, and operated on four of them,” he said.

Aarvold expressed hope to help more children when his colleagues visit the hospital in the next two months.

To read more of this report, click here

http://new.observer.org.sz/details.php?id=22425

 

Ex-Deputy Prime Minister (DPM)Themba Masuku received over R2million ANC alleged laundered corrupt monies from All Nations Bishop Bheki Lukhele

By Zweli Martin Dlamini, Swaziland News, 8 May, 2024

SOURCE 

MBABANE: Themba Masuku, the former Deputy Prime Minister(DPM) allegedly received over R2million alleged African National Congress (ANC) laundered corrupt monies from controversial Bishop Bheki Lukhele of the All Nations Church in Zion, an investigation by AmaBhungane Centre for Investigative Journalism in collaboration with the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ) has found.

In a report published this week and quoting a bundle of documents sourced from the Eswatini Financial Intelligence Unit (EFIU), the team of international investigative journalists found that, through his company-Lawuba Investments (Pty) Ltd, former DPM Themba Masuku, the then Shiselweni Regional Administrator (RA), sold a Farm to Bishop Lukhele at a suspicious inflated price amounting to over R2million in what was suspected to be an act of money laundering.

Referring to an article previously published by this Swaziland News, AmaBhungane quoted Bishop Lukhele having claimed that his money was legitimate.

This publication questioned the Bishop in 2019 after he was seen questionably accumulating wealth with no clear source of income.

“I can confidently confirm that my money is clean because it is received through the banks, it is traceable with all the proof. I don’t deposit money to the bank in cash except for the church offerings,” said Lukhele.

The investigative report produced under the ongoing highly effective investigative journalism project by Swazi Secrets, AmaBhungane and the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ)further reveals that, Judge Andreas Lukhele while practicing as a lawyer at Peter Dunseth Attorneys, was an alleged transferring attorney and a money-laundering conduit for Bishop Lukhele and former DPM Themba Masuku. 

A questionnaire was sent to the former DPM, however, he had not responded at the time of compiling this report.

To read more of this report, click here

https://swazilandnews.co.za/fundza.php?nguyiphi=6503

See also

Eswatini Financial Intelligence documents suggest that, ex-FSRA CEO Sandile Dlamini was sacrificed for government to be seen fighting corruption.

https://swazilandnews.co.za/fundza.php?nguyiphi=6504

 

SWAZI MEDIA COMMENTARY

Find us:

Blog: https://swazimedia.blogspot.com/

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/142383985790674

X (formerly Twitter): https://twitter.com  @Swazimedia

 

Friday, 26 January 2018

KINGDOM’S UNLIKELY GOVERNANCE AWARD

Swaziland has been given an award for ‘its contribution to peace, development and good governance’ by a group with links to the cultish Unification Church despite being ranked 34 out of 54 countries in Africa on governance by the world-renowned Mo Ibrahim Foundation.

The group making the award was the Universal Peace Federation (UPF). The Swazi Observer, a newspaper in effect owned by King Mswati III, who rules the kingdom as sub-Saharan Africa’s last absolute monarch, reported on Thursday (25 January 2018) that Swaziland won ‘the gold award’ at the UPF’s First Africa Summit.

No further details of the award were given. The award is surrounded in mystery. A website created by UPF to publicise the ceremony that took place in Dakar, Senegal on 18-19 January 2018 had pages headed ‘program’ and ‘press kit’ but the pages were blank.

The Observer reported, ‘The UPF leaders expressed their support for the country’s Vision 2022 and confidence that Swaziland can be a world leader in peace-building and model country for promoting peace, development and prosperity for its people.

‘They expressed their desire to meet Their Majesties and to mobilise resources and investments to support the country in its vision.  Other dignitaries from outside Swaziland also recognised and congratulated the country for its efforts in promoting peace.’

It reported Zombodze Emuva MP Dr Titus Thwala received the gold award on behalf of the kingdom.
The award for good governance comes as a surprise because Swaziland was ranked 34 out of 54 countries for overall governance in the 2017 Ibrahim Index of African Governance produced by the Mo Ibrahim Foundation. It received a score of 55.8 out of a hundred for rule of law. Other scores out of a hundred included: judicial independence (21.3); freedom of expression (22.8); civil liberties (33.3); and freedom of association and assembly (12.5).

The UPF was founded by Rev Sun Myung Moon who also created the Unification Church, popularly known as ‘the Moonies’. 

 After he died in 2012, the Daily Telegraph, a right-wing newspaper in the United Kingdom reported in an obituary, ‘Moon, a South Korean multi-millionaire businessman, discovered his vocation as the “second Messiah” in 1936, when he claimed to have met Jesus Christ on a Korean hillside, recognising Him from His picture. Jesus informed Moon that He had been unable to complete His mission on earth due to unforeseen circumstances, so Moon (Jesus went on) had been chosen to succeed Him and to establish the Kingdom of Heaven upon Earth.’

It added, ‘Moon gave every impression of believing his own sermons, and his blend of hard-sell Christianity and Eastern mysticism proved particularly appealing to the idealistic progeny of affluent Westerners, who were encouraged to hand over their worldly goods, reject their biological parents and accept the Moons as their “true parents”.’

It said, ‘Moon engendered widespread hostility among parents, alarmed at the changed personalities of their converted children. Some mounted lawsuits accusing Moon of practising brainwashing, and there were reports of cult members being kidnapped and de-programmed by “cult-busters”.’

The Telegraph obituary said, ‘While Moon’s adoring followers were persuaded to part with their worldly goods and were sent out unpaid on fund-raising missions, Moon was ferried round in chauffeur-driven limousines, took fishing holidays on his 50ft luxury cabin cruiser and lived in a sumptuous New York property modelled on a Korean palace. The source of Moon’s original capital remained a mystery, but the fact that the church’s dedicated workers received no wages certainly contributed to his success. In 2008 one estimate put Moon’s personal wealth at about $990 million.’

In an obituary, the New York Times reported, ‘As his church grew more prominent in the 1970s and ’80s, it became embroiled in lawsuits over soliciting funds, acquiring property and recruiting followers. Defectors wrote damaging books. From 1973 to 1986 at least 400 of the church’s flock were abducted by their family members to undergo “deprogramming,” according to an estimate by David G. Bromley, a professor of sociology at Virginia Commonwealth University and an expert on Mr Moon. The church denied that it had brainwashed its followers, saying members joined and stayed of their own free will.’

It added, ‘In the late 1970s, Mr Moon came under the scrutiny of federal authorities, mainly over allegations that he was involved in efforts by the South Korean government to bribe members of Congress to support President Park Chung-hee. A Congressional subcommittee said there was evidence of ties between Mr Moon and Korean intelligence, and that the church had raised money and moved it across borders in violation of immigration and local charity laws.

‘Then, in October 1981, Mr Moon was named in a 12-count federal indictment. He was accused of failing to report $150,000 in income from 1973 to 1975, a sum consisting of interest from $1.6 million that he had deposited in New York bank accounts in his own name, according to the indictment.’

Moon was convicted the next year of tax fraud and conspiracy to obstruct justice and sentenced to 18 months in prison. He was assigned to kitchen duty.

See also

SWAZILAND BOTTOM FOR PARTICIPATION
SWAZILAND GOVERNANCE APPALLING

Monday, 14 October 2013

SWAZILAND BOTTOM FOR PARTICIPATION

Swaziland ranks 47 out of 52 African nations for ‘Participation & Human Rights’ in the Ibrahim Index of African Governance (IIAG) published on Monday (14 October 2013).

And, in the sub-category ‘Participation’ it ranks 50 out of 52.

On a scale of 100, ‘Participation’ in Swaziland, which is ruled by King Mswati III, sub-Saharan Africa’s last absolute monarch, gets a score of 11.9. Meanwhile on ‘National Security’ it scores 90.

The 2013 IIAG provides full details of Swaziland’s performance across four categories of governance: Safety & Rule of Law, Participation & Human Rights, Sustainable Economic Opportunity and Human Development.

Despite improvements since 2000, Swaziland’s governance score remains below the continental average for Africa as well as the regional average for Southern Africa. Swaziland gets 50.8 out of a 100.

The IIAG provides a framework for stakeholders to assess the delivery of public goods and services, and policy outcomes, in every African nation.

Governance is defined by the Mo Ibrahim Foundation as ‘the provision of the political, social and economic public goods and services that a citizen has the right to expect from his or her state, and that a state has the responsibility to deliver to its citizens’.

See also

SWAZILAND IN GOVERNANCE DENIAL

Tuesday, 6 October 2009

SWAZI RULERS SILENT ON SERVICES

The Swazi Government has been slow to comment on news that Swaziland has scored below average for governance.

The Ibrahim Index of Governance published this week shows Swaziland scored 49.4 points out of a100 and was ranked 29th out of 53 African countries.

Within the Southern African region, Swaziland was ranked tenth. The kingdom scored below the Southern African regional average, which was 58.1 and scored just below the overall African continental average, which was 51.2.

By categories, Swaziland scored above the continental average in the categories of Safety and Rule of Law and Sustainable Economic Opportunity, but below the continental average in the categories of Participation and Human Rights and Human Development.

The Ibrahim Index is Africa’s leading assessment of governance, established to inform and empower the continent’s citizens. It measures the delivery of public goods and services to citizens by government and non-state actors across 84 indicators of governance.

In the past the publication of the Ibrahim Index has caused outrage within the Swaziland Government.

In 2007, Swaziland Government Press Secretary Percy Simelane tore into the Mo Ibrahim Foundation when it published its report showing the poor state of governance in the kingdom ruled by King Mswati III, sub-Saharan Africa’s last absolute monarch.

Simelane said Mo Ibrahim was dishonest for publishing the report, when he said, they had never made an investigation of Swaziland. I proved at the time that Simelane was talking through his hat and that it used dozens of sources of information to reach its conclusion.

Simelane was quoted saying that the analysis was done ‘by boys’ and ‘not men of honour’. The Times of Swaziland reported him saying that the ‘so-called experts’ were ignorant of what was happening in Swaziland.

Simelane said at the time that the Swaziland Government would do its own study to prove Mo Ibrahim wrong. Of course, it was all a distraction. The study was never done (or if it was done the results must have been so damning that it was never published).

The level of governance in Swaziland is atrocious. In January 2009 a report showing Swaziland’s position on governance from the US-based Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC) looked at whether nations are ‘ruling justly’, ‘investing in people’ and on ‘economic freedom.’

Here are some of the scores that Swaziland received (marks are out of 100).


Political rights (3)
Civil liberties (10)
Government effectiveness (17)
Rule of law (17)
Voice and accountability (17)

True to form, the Swaziland Deputy Prime Minister Themba Masuku challenged the findings of the MCC.

With the latest Mo Ibrahim report, it seems the Swazi Government has decided to keep silent.

According to the Swazi Observer, the newspaper in effect owned by King Mswati, when called for comment the phones of government ministers were left unanswered.

Tuesday, 6 January 2009

SWAZILAND GOVERNANCE APPALLING

The Swaziland Government is once again denying that the kingdom has an atrocious human rights record and an appalling scorecard on governance.


The latest report showing Swaziland’s position on governance is from the US-based Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC), which looked at whether nations are ‘ruling justly’, ‘investing in people’ and on ‘economic freedom.’


Here are some of the scores that Swaziland received (marks are out of 100).


Ruling Justly

Political rights (3)

Civil liberties (10)

Government effectiveness (17)

Rule of law (17)

Voice and accountability (17)


Economic freedom

Regulatory quality (23)

Land rights and access (9)

Business start up (14)

Trade policy (32)


According to the Swazi Observer yesterday (5 January 2009), the Swaziland Deputy Prime Minister Themba Masuku has challenged the findings of the MCC.


This is the standard response of the Swazi Government when faced with the truth about its appalling record.


In October 2007, I wrote at some length about how the government denied the findings of the Mo Ibrahim Foundation, which used about 50 sources of information in a report showing up Swaziland’s poor record. The Swazi Government tried to make it out that Mo Ibrahim was a ‘fly by night’ organisation and promised a detailed rebuttal of the report.


As far as I know such a rebuttal was never published.


So it is with the latest MCC report, the Swazi Government can deny all it wants, but the truth is out there for all to see.


(To read what I wrote last time click here).